Ross Esmond Notes

1st Blind Playtest: Tension

In June, we got the first round of feedback from blind playtesters. Most of it was easy to fix--clarifications and balance tweaks--but one piece of feedback prompted us to add a new system to our game, something we don't take lightly.

The feedback was that our ending felt anticlimactic, an issue that we were already worried about when we sent them the game. Luckily, the solution to this isn't elusive. Psykids is a co-op with an automated antagonist, and at a certain point in the game success became a certainty, which sucked all of the tension out of the game.

Tension in board games can manifest in a lot of ways, but there's a particular structure that I want to talk about with Psykids: your probability of winning or losing, and your proximity to winning or losing.

If your probability of winning or losing stays mostly balanced, tensions will generally stay high. Pandemic, for example, tends to keep the tension all the way through. It's balanced in such a way that even up to the last turn, you usually don't know how it's going to end, maintaining the tension up to the last turn.

TODO: A picture of the probability of winning.

The other aspect to tension is your proximity to winning or losing. At the start of most games, you're far away from either outcome, and the tension is relatively low. Near the end, however, if you're close to either outcome, it gets much higher. Sky Team can be incredibly tense all the way through, because you're never far away from one of its five loss conditions.

TODO: A picture of the proximity of losing.

TODO: Continue on about Psykids.

cutting floor

Importantly, these factors only matter if the player is aware of them. I love Spirit Island, but the one criticism that I kind-of agree with is that it can have an underwhelming ending. Its complexity, simultaneous play, and multiple win conditions can result in an unexpected win, which can be less satisfying than those in Pandemic or Sky Team.