Ross Esmond Notes

Duct Taping Antagonists to Player Characters

Many co-op and solo games have asymmetry in their player characters, antagonists, or both, but they usually focus on one or the other. Spirit Island has incredibly distinct player characters, but the antagonists are comparitively much more similar to each other. Final Girl, on the other hand, has incredibly distinct antagonists, but comparitively similar player characters (Final Girls).

Part of the reason why this happens is because each additional player character creates restrictions on your design-space for antagonists, and vice versa. If a player character, say, is immune to traps, you can't have an antagonist who is fully solved by being immune to traps.

Spirit Island does a weird thing where the default antagonist does everything: they spawn explorers, towns, cities, and eventually blight. Spirits (player characters) can then counter any part of this to prevent the eventual ravage, but this means that none of the antagonists can skip any particular step, because that would completely overpower a Spirit that specializes in preventing that step.

Final Girl is the opposite. Antagonists are extremely varied. The Poltergeist, for example, can't take any damage: a big departure from other antagonists. Unlike in Spirit Island, though, the Final Girls (player characters) all have the same actions available to them, so the loss of attacks affects them all roughly equally. If Final Girls all came with unique actions like in Spirit Island, a Final Girl who specializes in dealing damage would be inviable against the Poltergeist.

This is a problem we face with Psykids, except Psykids has a feature that allows us to sneak game-breaking abilties onto player characters without it ruining the game in some combinations. Our antagonists are the player characters possessed by Phobos, meaning you can't play against that antagonist with that player character.

Show the board.

This gives us one player character for each antagonist to whom we can give the game breaking abilties. Eichii, for example, is especially good at manipulating dice, and Eichii's possessed form has an objective that is all about manipulating dice. If you could play Eichii against Eichii, he would more-or-less solve the game, but you can't, so you're forced to figure out the dice manipulation with characters for whom that will be a challenge.

Show Eichii

This works thematically too. A common trope in fiction is that the "evil" version of a character is difficult for anyone else to solve. In Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the only person that could usually handle other slayers was Buffy, but even she was no match against late Dark Willow. This trope combines with the mechanics to help you "miss" a character once they're possessed. If you're familiar with Eichii's abilities, it makes you think "I wish Eichii were here."

Eichii isn't the only character that we've done this for. All Psykids have it to varying degrees: Laila is the best fighter, so her possessed form makes you fight, Hyun is the best at acquiring items, so her possessed form sends you on a scavenger hunt, etc. With eight characters, we've removed only eight of the sixty four combinations, but it has allowed us to diversify their abilities and antagonist forms beyond what would normally be viable.