Top Level Principles
These are the core, most universal principles that serve as the foundation of most design decisions. Many mechanics exist solely to satisfy one of these principles
Reduce Deadtime
I'm using the term Deadtime instead of Downtime here, as I am not just referring to the time players are waiting between turns. Deadtime is any time during a game where the players become disengaged with the game, which can happen for a few reasons:
- Downtime—The player is neither considering their next move or excitedly observing another players move. This occures during opponents turns if a player is not interested in their opponents (or teammates) actions, usually because those actions have little affect on a players next move.
- Boring admin—Effectively downtime, but where no player is taking a turn, but the result of the admin is not interesting enough to matter to the players.
- Player elimination—The most direct form of Deadtime, a player is literally no longer allowed to play the game, but a new game cannot start until the remaining players reach a conclusion.
- Effective player elimination—A player has no chance of winning, but must keep playing despite not being able to affect their outcome. The player is effectively eliminated, but the rules say that they must still take actions.
- No player agency—The player has no actions on their turn which will meaningfully affect the game, or there is only one action the player can reasonably make. Only having one option causes a player to not care about the game state and to not have to reason about their next move, causing disengagement.
- Too much luck—If players don't feel like their choices have any affect on the outcome of the game, they will stop reasoning about their choices.
Deadtime is about engagement, not about who is actively taking their turn. A player could have no agency in any given moment, but if they are interested in what is happening, that is not deadtime for that player. Engagement in strategy games mostly comes from the current actions affecting the players future actions, such that observing those actions feels relevant and gives a player something new to reason about.
Associated Mechanics & Principles
Many mechanics and lower level design principles exist to reduce deadtime.
Player Interaction
Worker placement blocks a space, action drafting takes a space, trick taking sets the lead suit, etc. Player interaction makes an opponents turn matter, keeping players engaged. Remember that positive player interaction exists too, though, and can have the same desired effect.
Remove admin phases
Instead of adding "upkeep" phases to turns or rounds, try to fold these phases into player actions. For example, instead of having an income phase at the begining of turns, give the player a "produce" action that they may choose to perform as one of their turns. This makes production a choice and can allow for more agency. It also makes individual turns faster and may reduce downtime.
If you want to limit a players income by removing the ability to repeatedly produce several turns in a row, you can introduce some form of Action Retrieval.
End the game when a player is eliminated
As seen in Altay and Thunderroad, the game can come to an end the moment any player is eliminated, so that a new game can start and players aren't left out for too long. You could also have the eliminated player be the sole loser, as in Jenga or Cockroach Poker.
Catch up mechanics
Catch up mechanics are designed to ensure that a player has never lost until the game ends, staving off effective player elimination.
Hide the lead player
If the lead player is not easily identifiable, then players will stay engaged even if they have effectively already lost.
Variety of turns
Games can become boring if the player has to take the same action turn after turn. For this reason, most modern games will incentivise or force some variety of turns.
Associated Mechanics
Almost every game has at least one mechanic to produce variety of turns.
Limited resources
If a resource is limited and spending it is advantagous, players will naturally cycle through gaining that resource and spending that resource. Limited resources effectively act as negative feedback on performing the same action repeatedly.
Resource Capacities
As with limited resources, where running out of a resource can force you to change your tactics, a resource capacity can force you to change tactics when you fill up on a resource. This can be useful when banking a resource and dumping it all at once is actually advantagous. For example, in Race for the Galaxy, you can ship all of your resources all at once with one shipment action, and the bonus for shipping is often victory points. This leaves no reason not to build up resources for the whole game, only shipping near the end, except the players may only have one resource on each production structure, which fill up after one production action. This means that shipping becomes necessary to gain any benefit from further production.
Deck, Bag, Dice Pool Building
If your turn is given cycling input randomness, you will frequently have to perform different action on account of your drawn resources.
Rondel
Most rondels in games charge the player for jumping too many spaces, or introduce some other incentive to not travel very far around the rondel, forcing players to cycle through many actions around the rondel.
Action Drafting
Worker Placement games and other forms of action drafting force players to draft new actions as prior actions become blocked.
Action Retrieval
As seen with Hand Management like in Concordia or Spice Road, Action Retrieval incentivises players to perform each action in turn before recalling their actions for reuse.
Direct Ban
Scythe uses a pawn which prevents you from performing the same action twice in a row—the most direct approach.